Jingxian County a hospital handwriting forgery risk warning sentenced to compensation of 8 yu-y580

A hospital in Jingxian County on risk warning   handwriting fraud; was sentenced to compensate 8 yuan – Anhui channel people.com.cn — an online news according to the Anhui daily news in patients with right leg popliteal cyst surgery in hospital, informed consent before the resection, the "risk category" and "complications" column unexpectedly not to write clearly the potential risks and there may be complications, so that patients directly sign. The patient suffered from sequela after operation, leading to disability and brought the hospital to court. Hospital temporary fraud, fill out the risk notice on the consent form. The day before, the Jingxian County hospital "acting" is found in the court, the trial was sentenced to compensation for economic losses were 8 yuan. "Risk column" blank, let the patient sign Dong Jiakang (alias) is Jingxian County people, in recent years, the right knee grew a packet. In November 4, 2014, Dong Jiakang went to a hospital in Jingxian County for treatment, the doctor diagnosis was right popliteal cyst. The hospital let Dong Ieyasu surgery signed informed consent, the implementation of the right popliteal cyst resection. Dong Jiakang introduced, in the preoperative informed consentform, he felt strange, risk of "bar" and "complications bar" this book, are almost blank, only a few paintings of chinese". "I thought it was a minor operation, and there was no risk, so I signed it."." Dong Jiakang called. Unexpectedly, Dong’s right lower limb swelling and pain is more serious. In November 21st, he came to the hospital again and was diagnosed with deep vein thrombosis of the right lower extremity. After the identification, his right lower limb loss function more than 10%, constitute the grade ten disability. Dong Jiakang removed many hospitals, spend more than 4 yuan medical expenses. Patients left sequelae, found that the book was tampered with, in January 2015, Dong Jiakang to the risk of inadequate preoperative inform the grounds of the fault, the hospital to court. In the middle, he was surprised to find that at the time he signed the informed consent form of surgery, there was a lot of words in the "risk column" and "complications column", which were almost empty. It was about the risk of operation and the complications that may arise. The hospital was blatantly fabricated in the informed consent form before the operation." Dong Jiakang was shocked, but the hospital insisted that these words were written before Dong signed, not later filling. Both Dong Jiakang apply to the court, each one sticks to his argument, the formation time of identification of handwriting writing. Jingxian County court commissioned a professional organization to identify handwriting formation time, the results are surprising: the other handwriting and Dong signature handwriting after the formation of additional. After the appraisal report came out, the hospital had nothing to say and accepted the report." Jingxian County court judge Qi Junshi told reporters. The hospital did not inform obligations were sentenced to compensate 8 yuan, Dong Jiakang asked the court to compensate the hospital for medical expenses and other economic losses of more than 33 yuan. The court held that someone’s Hospital let Dong Ieyasu signed informed consent, did not explicitly write clearly the risks and possible complications, informed consent part of the book "risk" and "complications" bar bar, line add after writing with Dong Jiakang signature, should be regarded as someone fails to perform the corresponding hospital patients the risk disclosure obligations, damage to the patient’s right to know. Patient Dong Jiakang 泾县一医院笔迹造假补上风险提示 被判赔偿8万余元–安徽频道–人民网   中安在线讯 据安徽商报消息 患者右腿右腘窝囊肿,医院在手术切除前的知情同意书上,“风险栏”及“并发症栏”竟然不写清楚可能存在的风险和并发症隐患,直接让患者签字。患者术后出现后遗症,导致伤残,将医院告上法院。医院临时造假,在同意书上加填风险告示。日前,泾县一医院的“演技”在法庭上被识破,一审被判赔偿患者经济损失8万余元。   “风险栏”一片空白就让患者签字   董家康(化名)是泾县人,近年来右膝长出一个包块。 2014年11月4日,董家康去泾县某医院治疗,医生症断为右腘窝囊肿。医院让董家康签署了手术治疗知情同意书,实施右腘窝囊肿切除术。   董家康介绍,在术前知情同意书上签字时,他就感觉奇怪,告知书上有“风险栏”和“并发症栏”,都几乎空白,只是画了几个“√”。“我以为是个小手术,没什么风险,就签了字。”董家康称。   没想到,手术后董家康右下肢肿痛更严重了。 11月21日,他再次来到医院检查,经诊断为右下肢深静脉血栓。后经鉴定,他的右下肢丧失功能10%以上,构成十级伤残。董家康辗转至多家医院,花去医药费4万余元。   患者留下后遗症发现告知书被篡改   2015年1月,董家康以手术前风险告知不充分等过错为由,将医院告上法庭。这中间,他吃惊地发现,自己当时签字的手术治疗知情同意书上,原本几乎空白的“风险栏”和“并发症栏”凭空多出很多字,是关于手术风险和可能引发的并发症。“医院竟公然在术前知情同意书上造假。”董家康深感震惊,但医院方面坚称这些字在董家康签字前就写了的,并非后期加填上去的。双方各执一词,董家康向法院申请,对笔迹书写形成时间进行鉴定。   泾县法院委托专业机构对笔迹书写形成时间进行鉴定,结果令人大跌眼镜:是在其他笔迹和董某签名的笔迹书写形成之后另行添加。“鉴定报告出来后,医院也没有话说,认可了这份报告。”泾县法院法官齐军仕告诉记者。   医院未尽告知义务被判赔8万余元   董家康要求法院判决医院赔偿自己医药费等经济损失33万余元。   法院认为,涉事医院让董家康签署知情同意书时,并未明确写清楚可能存在的风险和并发症,知情同意书上“风险”栏及“并发症”栏中部分内容,系在患者董家康签名之后另行添加书写,应视为涉事医院未向患者履行相应的风险告知义务,损害了患者的知情权。患者董家康经济损失20.5万余元,但损害后果主要源于其自身疾病的发展,法院判决泾县某医院赔偿他经济损失的40%即8万余元。   该案中,判定医院未尽到术前风险告知义务的关键,是对那张存在争议的术前告知书笔迹痕迹书写形成时间的鉴定。主审法官齐军仕介绍,他也遇到过有些案件当事人在收借条、合同等文本上事后造假的情况,以为能瞒天过海,“其实专业的检测鉴定机构,能鉴定出这些字迹谁先写、谁后写。通过墨汁的挥发程度、纸张背面的笔痕等,都能得出准确的鉴定结果。”齐军仕提醒,任何造假欺瞒的拙劣表演,都能被戳穿。 (责编:金蕾欣、张磊)相关的主题文章: